Nickels may not get as much attention as their bigger cousins—the quarter or the dollar—but some of these five-cent coins can be surprisingly valuable. While most nickels you find in your pocket are worth exactly five cents, a few rare varieties have gained significant value over time, making them sought-after items for collectors. Here’s a rundown of the top 10 most valuable American nickels you might still encounter today.
1. 1913 Liberty Head Nickel
Although technically not in general circulation, the 1913 Liberty Head Nickel is the holy grail for collectors. Only five known examples exist, with one selling for over $4.5 million at auction. Keep an eye out for this rare find!
2. 1936 Buffalo Nickel (3-Legged)
This error coin features a Buffalo missing its front leg, making it a rarity. In good condition, it can fetch between $5,000 and $10,000. Spotting one in circulation is a long shot, but worth checking your pocket change.
3. 1939 Jefferson Nickel
The 1939 nickel can be quite valuable, especially if it has the “D” mintmark from the Denver Mint. Coins in excellent condition can sell for upwards of $1,000, especially those graded MS 65 or higher.
4. 1942-P (Silver) Jefferson Nickel
In response to World War II, the U.S. Mint struck nickels using silver in 1942. These coins are marked with a “P” mintmark and can be worth around $3 to $5 in average condition, with higher grades significantly increasing their value.
5. 1950-D Jefferson Nickel
This coin is rare due to a limited mintage, with its value climbing to around $5,000 or more, depending on its condition. The “D” mintmark is key to identifying this valuable piece.
6. 1964 Jefferson Nickel (D)
The 1964-D nickel is another underrated find. While most are worth only five cents, the error variety can be worth as much as $3,500 to $4,000, especially if it displays a double die obverse.
7. 1971-S Proof Jefferson Nickel
Struck as a proof coin, the 1971-S nickel can be worth between $2 and $5 for an average example, but higher-quality coins can fetch up to $50 or more.
8. 1979-P Jefferson Nickel (DDO)
This coin features a distinctive doubling on the obverse and can be valued between $500 and $1,500, depending on its condition. Keep an eye out for this minting error!
9. 1987-P Jefferson Nickel (DDO)
Similar to its 1979 counterpart, the 1987-P nickel features double die obverse characteristics. Collectors pay up to $100 for specimens in excellent condition.
10. 2004 Wisconsin Quarter (Extra Leaf)
While technically a quarter, the 2004 Wisconsin quarter features a design similar to a nickel and is worth mentioning due to its unique “extra leaf” variety. It can be worth $1,000 or more in pristine condition, making it a noteworthy find.
While most nickels you’ll encounter are worth just a nickel, a select few can pack a hefty punch in the collector’s market. Always check your change for these valuable varieties, as you might be surprised at what you find! Happy hunting!
